Who "you" are
- The bet
- Players won't make an account for a hobby tool, so remembering them by device is enough.
- The risk
- If the app forgets or confuses who you are, you see someone else's data on your card and stop trusting everything the team shares.
- How sure
- Low. It was a convenience call to keep sign-up friction at zero, not something I tested with players.
- What happened
- It broke four different ways: the wrong player marked as "you," old names pre-filled, rejoining a team failing, and lane data surviving a cleared cache. Patching each symptom didn't hold, so I rebuilt identity on real accounts.
- Options I considered
-
- Remember the deviceShipped, failed
- Sign in with GoogleBuilt, then replaced
- Username and passwordChosen
Why I switched from Google: on a team tool, your username is your identity, and I wanted players picking the name their teammates know, not inheriting their Google one. The trade-off: I now own account recovery and password rules, which Google would have handled for me. I accepted that.